The Real Story Behind Building community.themakerdad.com

I just launched community.themakerdad.com, and the announcement post makes it sound clean. Here's the version that didn't make it into that post: the weeks of second-guessing, the software comparisons, and the "is this even the right time" spiral that came with actually building it.

When I started The Maker Dad a couple of months back, I wanted a spot where other makers, woodworkers, and creators could hang out and share what they're working on. The problem was figuring out how to actually build that without burning money on a community that has nobody in it yet.

Picking the platform

I looked at a lot of options: Zenforo, Discourse, NodeBB, SMF, and newer platforms like Circle and Mighty Networks. Circle and Mighty Networks were tempting, but I didn't want to end up paying around a hundred dollars a month, something like twelve hundred a year, for a community that's just getting started with no one in it yet. That math didn't sit right with me.

I landed on Invision Community for a simple reason: I already had an active license, and the hosting was already paid for the year. It also came with a blog and article system, downloads, a gallery, forums, and commerce, all built into the core software. Compare that to Zenforo, which is a great forum platform, but anything beyond the forum itself means paying for plugins on top. Invision has all of that baked in, which matters a lot when the long-term plan is to use it as a Patreon and Fourthwall replacement, too.

What's actually live right now

The site isn't a copy of the main blog. I set up a section called "From the Shop Floor" that takes posts from the main site and reworks them, not word for word, so it doesn't step on the SEO of themakerdad.com. Each post links back to the original and asks a question to get people talking. When someone comments, it shows up as a thread in the forums, so the forum is doing double duty as a comment system.

Ghost stays the main SEO hub since it's genuinely good at getting blog posts and newsletters picked up by search, or AI engines now, honestly [NOTE: you mentioned this as an aside, kept it brief and light rather than turning it into a full tangent, let me know if you want more said here]. Invision is where the community, storefront, and memberships will eventually live, replacing Patreon and Fourthwall, so everything sits in one place instead of three separate systems.

The part nobody sees

Figuring out the category structure took weeks. What sections to start with, what to name them, what to hide for now. I've got a couple of sections like the store and a Q&A/feedback area sitting there empty right now, more placeholders than anything, and I'll probably keep them hidden until there's actual activity to justify them.

The honest answer is this is never really finished. If people start piling into one topic, like power tools, that discussion probably needs to graduate into its own category eventually, so it doesn't crowd out everything else. If a section goes quiet, it can get folded into something else until interest picks back up. It's a living structure, not a one-time setup.

Was this even the right time

I kept going back and forth on this. Is now really the moment to launch a community and forum side of The Maker Dad? Honestly, probably not. But it's built now, and that means as I keep making videos and turning transcripts into blog posts, there's already a home for that content to live and grow into. Better to have done the structural work now than to scramble to build it later once people actually show up.

That's the real story behind community.themakerdad.com: less a grand launch, more months of quiet decision making that finally has something to show for it. If it doesn't take off, I'll make that call in six months to a year. For now, it's there, and it's good enough.

Want the full walkthrough, including me clicking through the actual site? Check out the podcast episode or catch the video version on YouTube.

Later, taters.

Josh

Written by

Share

Copied